A Question of Cannibalism
木曜日, 9月 07, 2006

Munchen

I just saw Poiter, I mean Eric Bana, in Spielberg's Munich. Sorry to be late, but I'm not a big movie person - the only thing which could draw me to the exorbitant cinema prices would be a Johnny Depp appearance. Sigh.

Anyway, say what you may, I was impressed. The film doesn't say anything new, in particular, but I do appreciate it for bringing up important issue in an approachable way - as Spielberg says in the featured interview, he wanted to make people aware of some of the factors involved in the seemingly never-ending Israel-Palestine struggle, and the easiest way to do that is characterisation and empathy. Admirably, for a Jewish-descended American (often derided as the worst of the worst when it comes to impartiality in this debate), he strives to present both "sides" of the story and the competing claims for land and security, albeit through minor characters.

Munich presents events that allegedly happened 30 years ago, but the issues raised, unfortunately, are still more than relevant today. Where does patriotism bleed into extremism? What is most important to you - your family, your country, or human life and dignity? How can you resolve two incompatible points of view? Is violence an effective response to violence? When will Bana return to comedy?


The height of comedy: 189 cm, sans coiffure.

It's a big-budget Hollywood flick, but Spielberg does them well. I cried at the end of Schindler's List. I didn't cry this time (it wasn't all that sad, really) but the background is probably more relevant to a contemporary audience. Check the film out. At worst, an entertaining, suspenseful couple of hours; at best, a reflection on trading an eye for an eye until everyone is blind. 
Comments:
Yo.

Munich was good alright. He managed to present both sides without resorting to awkward monologues. The closest he came was the scene where the israelis meet the palestinians in the hideout, but pretend they're someone else, and have a political discussion. But that scene works really well. Kudos steven.
As far as I can remember the film was attacked bitterly by both sides so it must have been pretty balanced.

Welcome back to the world of blogging.
More comments on your other posts.
 
Fuckin' whatever dot com. What can Mr ET tell me about Munich that I couldn't/didn't already know from books, documentaries, world history et al? I just don't see the point. Is the actual event not 'dramatic' enough, so a documentary won't do...actual photos blasted bodies on the tarmac in 'one day in september' are much more titilating. Anyway, I vote 'no' to politics in movies and pop music!

- David
 
コメントを投稿

<< Home
For too long, puritanical love-monkeys have been talking ill of one of our little planet's most time-honoured gastronomical past-times. Have YOUR say in reclaiming your right to eat your friends. If god had meant us not to eat human flesh, why did he make it so damn tasty?

名前:
場所: Perth, Australia
ARCHIVES
31/01/05
01/02/05
05/02/05
06/02/05
08/02/05
10/02/05
05/03/05
25/03/05
31/03/05
05/04/05
07/04/05
10/04/05
24/06/05
17/07/05
19/07/05
21/07/05
05/08/05
09/08/05
12/08/05
23/08/05
25/08/05
26/08/05
03/09/05
26/09/05
22/10/05
24/10/05
01/12/05
23/12/05
22/01/06
23/01/06
18/02/06
19/02/06
20/02/06
27/02/06
17/03/06
19/03/06
06/04/06
08/04/06
12/04/06
13/04/06
14/04/06
18/04/06
20/04/06
25/04/06
26/04/06
27/04/06
14/05/06
17/05/06
20/05/06
22/05/06
24/05/06
26/05/06
28/08/06
30/08/06
04/09/06
06/09/06
07/09/06
13/09/06
16/12/06
18/01/07
30/01/07
03/02/07
19/02/07
24/06/07

Powered by Blogger